Making Buying & Selling Items In Communities Safer
Product
Responsive Web App
Role
Senior Designer
Category
Buy & Sell, Community
When
October 2020 - May 2022
Context
Verticalscope owns over 1600 online forum communities with a varying amount of different user types.
Problem
Existing posting capabilities within the forum were being misused resulting in a poor user experience, making it challenging for the company to ensure security against spammers and scammers.
Research
When conducting user research, I first connected with users through the forums themselves to understand the current sentiment towards buying & selling items.

Specific interviews were also done with a few select users to have coverage over all the user types.
Tyler Nguyen
Frustrated User
As someone who primarily uses my smartphone for everything, I really feel the mobile version of this app could be more intuitive.
Karen Wallace
Frustrated User
I feel the interface for the desktop application quite challenging to navigate. The buttons are too small and the menus are overly complicated.
George Bennett
Frustrated User
I'm not very tech-savvy and I'm constantly worried about clicking something wrong and falling for a scam.
User Survey
User types were divided by age groups, as the feedback for each age group varied. The three age groups were 60+, 40-60, and 20-40.
Ages 18-40
Ages 40-60
Ages 60+
38 Requests
More Intuitive UI
43 Requests
Spam/Scam Security
12 Requests
Mobile Experience
Insights
Based on the research done, it became clear that the largest challenge was going to be addressing spammers and scammers in a meaningful way.

We introduced a reputation system that would help users denote who was reputable within the community compared to someone who was fairly new with hardly any human-looking activity on the platform.

Some of the factors that played into our reputation system was registration date, number of posts made, positive reviews, and more.
User Flow Diagrams
By ensuring a stringent account registration and onboarding process that was largely based on time-related account milestones, the risk of spam and scams was minimized, providing a safer environment for users.
Low Fidelity Wireframes
Important points of the user’s flow were included in other feature flows that contributed to the user’s reputation, such as leaving a review for a buyer after marking an item as sold.
High Fidelity Designs
The primary goal of this work was to provide forum users with a trustworthy, safe, and engaging marketplace experience by introducing dedicated marketplace features.
Takeaway Metrics
The Marketplace addition to forum communities had a wide release with a high level of user satisfaction. The amount of spam and scam appearances in communities reduced by a large amount after time-based account milestones needed to be met in order for users to unlock Marketplace features beyond buying.
40% Reduction
in known spam/scam tactic appearances.
100+ Million
Monthly Active Users in 1600+ communities.
$20+ Million
in total Marketplace postings.